Email Brennan
Group captive insurance

Your renewal came in high. You may not have to live with it for a year.

A group captive is an insurance company owned by the well-run companies it insures. Your premium is based on your own losses, the part that isn't spent on claims comes back to you, and it can quote you mid-term.

  • 98% of members stay every year.
  • "The only regret I have is not joining sooner."
Email me — I'd like to see my numbers

Short version below. Every section opens up if you want the detail.

How it works

  1. Your premium goes into a company you part-own. Only well-run companies are let in, and your price follows your own claims, not everyone else's.
  2. It is split in two, and you see every line. About 60% goes into loss funds that pay claims. About 40% pays the operating costs that run the program.
  3. Unused loss-fund money comes back to you. If your claims come in under your loss funds, the money that is left is returned to you. With regular insurance, the insurer keeps it.
Where your premium goes in a group captive Your premium is split in two: about 60% goes into loss funds that pay claims, and about 40% pays operating costs. Loss-fund money that is not used on claims comes back to you. Your premium About 60% Loss funds: they pay claims About 40% Operating costs What claims don't use comes back to you
Learn more: the loss funds (the A fund and the B fund)

The loss funds are two funds, stacked in layers, and every claim climbs those layers from the bottom. About 60% of premium is typical; in some groups it runs a little over 70%.

The A fund is the bottom layer. It pays the first part of every claim, from $1 to $150,000. It is called the frequency fund because it handles the small, frequent claims, and it holds most of the premium.

The B fund, also called the severity fund, pays the part of a claim from $150,001 up to the retention, and it also pays once the A fund is used up. The retention is how much of each claim the captive pays itself before reinsurance takes over: $400,000 in this example.

Anything above the retention is paid by the reinsurance carrier, up to where the umbrella policy starts.

The layers every claim climbs From the bottom: the A fund pays from $1 to $150,000 of every claim; the B fund pays from $150,001 up to the $400,000 retention; reinsurance pays above $400,000; the umbrella policy covers the rest of a very large claim. Umbrella policy the rest of a very large claim Reinsurance above $400,000 B fund: the severity fund $150,001 up to the $400,000 retention A fund: the frequency fund $1 to $150,000 of every claim
Learn more: how a claim gets paid

A claim is paid from the bottom up, and the company's own money always goes first: its A fund, then its B fund, then risk sharing with the group up to the retention, then reinsurance.

Take an example company with an A fund of $200,000 and a B fund of $32,000. A $75,000 claim has already come in, so $125,000 is left in its A fund. Now a much bigger claim arrives: $500,000.

  1. Everything left in its A fund: $125,000
  2. Then the whole B fund: $32,000
  3. Risk sharing covers the rest, up to the $400,000 retention: $243,000
  4. Reinsurance pays the part above the retention: $100,000
Who pays a $500,000 claim in the example One bar for the $500,000 claim, in four parts: the A fund pays $125,000, the B fund $32,000, risk sharing with the group $243,000 up to the $400,000 retention, and reinsurance the last $100,000. $400,000 retention A fund B fund Risk sharing Reinsurance
Learn more: what the 40% pays for

Operating costs are what it takes to run the captive: reinsurance, claims handling, management, accounting and regulatory fees.

A captive quote shows the exact amount for each one, so every dollar of the price is shown to you.

Operating costs are spent either way, whether the year has claims or not, which is why they are called below-the-line costs. They are not the money that comes back. The loss funds are.

Every insurer runs the same simple equation: premium comes in, operating costs and claims go out, and whatever is left over is the insurance company's profit. In a group captive the members own that company, so they share in what is left.

What happens in a bad year

A fair question about any captive: what if I have a big claim? You are not on your own. A group captive is not self-insurance. It operates like a normal insurance company.

  • An A-rated carrier sits above the captive. The captive does not stand by itself.
  • Reinsurance pays the large claims. The big ones do not come out of your funds alone.
  • Your worst case is known every year. Losses are capped, so you know the most a bad year can cost you before the year starts.

It works best for owners who plan to stay several years.

Learn more: assessments

If a company's A fund and B fund are both empty and another claim comes in, the captive fronts the money. This is called an assessment: an extra amount the company owes the captive and repays over time.

It is capped. The most a company can be assessed is one times its A fund: $200,000 for the example company with a $200,000 A fund.

It is repaid over three years, quarterly: typically 50% in the first year, then 25% and 25%. Some groups use a 50 / 30 / 20 split. Either way, the amount and the schedule are known in advance, so the company can budget for them.

In traditional insurance, a bad year shows up at renewal instead: the insurer may send a large increase about 30 days before renewal, or decline to renew at all.

How an assessment is typically repaid Three years: 50% in the first year, 25% in the second and 25% in the third. Year 1 50% Year 2 25% Year 3 25%
Learn more: risk sharing

Risk sharing means members chip in on each other's larger claims. It sits in the B fund: typically 6 to 15% of the B fund goes to it.

When a large claim uses up a member's own A fund and B fund, risk sharing covers the rest, up to the retention. Above the retention, reinsurance pays.

It is based on size. A smaller member contributes much less to the group's large claims than a much larger member does.

That is why a captive only accepts well-run companies with strong safety programs. Members are very rarely removed, and only with years of notice.

Who it fits, and who it doesn't

A good fit

  • Well-run companies whose renewal is higher than their loss record deserves.
  • Owners who plan to stay several years.
  • Owners who want to see where every premium dollar goes.

Not a fit

  • An owner planning to sell in the next two to three years.
  • A company with frequent claims. Members are let in on their record.

How your price is built

Your price follows your own claims. An actuary turns your last five years into one number for next year. Run clean and that number falls, and your premium with it.

Learn more: your price comes from your own losses

Pricing starts by sorting claims by size. An actuary, the specialist who prices insurance, separates small, frequent claims from large ones. Small claims are predictable, like free throws in basketball; large ones are like half-court shots, so they are priced apart.

Claims also keep growing after the day they happen. An injury claim first estimated at $20,000 can close at $60,000 a couple of years later: treatment runs longer, lawyers get involved, and the final bill is bigger than the first estimate. So young years are grown to their likely final cost.

One shock loss is capped at $150,000 in the loss pick, so a single bad claim does not set your price.

Large members are priced mostly on their own record; smaller ones lean on the group until they build one.

Learn more: the loss pick becomes the A fund

Each of your last five years becomes a cost per unit, in today's dollars. Recent years count the most; older years count less. The weighted average is the loss pick.

The loss pick times the units you have today is the A fund. In this example:

$5,093 per unit × 28 units = $142,604 the loss pick × units today = the A fund

The B fund and the operating costs are then figured as percentages of it. In a captive, most amounts are figured as a percentage of the A fund, so it is the number to watch. For the example company with a $200,000 A fund, the B fund is 16% of the A fund: $32,000.

See it on your own numbers

Move the sliders to your own premium and claims.

$250,000
$50,000
$150,000
$120,000
In a member-owned captive, this comes back to you:
$150,000
on $450,000 premium · 60% loss fund − $120,000 claims

Illustrative. This calculator sets aside about 40% for fixed program costs; the 60% loss fund, less your paid claims, is what's returned to members. Actual distributions depend on the captive's overall performance. A captive also means your company carries more of its own risk — the return above only exists because you're taking on the loss fund.

Owning it

A captive is an insurance company owned and controlled by its members. Each member owns a share, votes on changes and shares in the underwriting profit.

Learn more: what it takes to join

You become an owner. Joining means buying one share of stock in the captive. A share typically costs $15,000 to $40,000, depending on the group. It is your ownership stake, not a fee, and you get it back if you ever leave.

Collateral: a security deposit. Like the deposit on a lease, it is not a payment and is not spent. You can post it as cash or as a letter of credit. Cash collateral is invested alongside the premium and grows, and it is only touched if a member fails to pay what it owes.

Collateral equals two thirds of the A fund, and you post it in three equal parts: the same third in each of your first three years. On a $200,000 A fund that is about $44,000 a year, about $133,000 in all. It does not go up each year. After year 3 it is only adjusted if your A fund grows or shrinks.

Collateral posted in three equal parts, on a $200,000 A fund The same amount, about $44,000, is posted in each of the first three years: $44,000 in all after year 1, $88,000 after year 2, $133,000 after year 3. +$44,000 Year 1 $44,000 in all +$44,000 Year 2 $88,000 in all +$44,000 Year 3 $133,000 in all
Learn more: when money comes back

Unused loss-fund money comes back as distributions. The first one typically comes at the end of year three, because a year needs about three years for its claims to close.

So year 1's money comes back at the end of year 3, as year 4 begins. Year 2's comes back at the end of year 4, as year 5 begins, and so on: after the first, about one distribution every year.

An open claim holds back only its reserve. Take a year with $250,000 in its funds and one lawsuit reserved at $180,000: the clean portion is released, and only the reserve waits.

When each year's unused money comes back A line runs from year 1 to year 4: year 1's money comes back at the end of year 3, as year 4 begins. A second line runs from year 2 to year 5: year 2's money comes back at the end of year 4. After that, about one distribution every year. Year 1's money Year 1 Year 2 Year 3 Year 4 Year 5 Year 2's money

What five years can look like

A made-up company, five years in, with two hard years on purpose. An example, not a quote or a promise.

Five years in a group captive, year by year Years 1, 3 and 5 return $163,200, $167,520 and $199,680. Years 2 and 4 bring assessments of $35,000 and $34,600. Net equity after five years is $460,800. +$163,200 Year 1 $35,000 Year 2 +$167,520 Year 3 $34,600 Year 4 +$199,680 Year 5
YearWhat happenedResult
1A normal yearPremium $580,000Loss funds $348,000Claims $180,000+$163,200came back
2One $500,000 claimPremium $609,000Loss funds $365,400Claims $665,000$35,000assessment
3A normal yearPremium $638,000Loss funds $382,800Claims $210,000+$167,520came back
441 small claimsPremium $609,000Loss funds $365,400Claims $400,000$34,600assessment
5A normal yearPremium $667,000Loss funds $400,200Claims $195,000+$199,680came back
Total premium, five years$3,103,000
Of that, into the loss funds (60%)$1,861,800
Net equity after five years$460,800

In a good year, what comes back is the loss funds less the claims, less that year's share of risk sharing. That is $530,400 back from the three good years, less $69,600 in assessments from the two hard ones. The $230,000 of collateral posted along the way is separate, and still theirs.

Two ways to look. No form.

Looking costs nothing and commits you to nothing, and either one can be done mid-term.

Email me — I'd like to see my numbers

Brennan tells you exactly what to send, then shows you what you would have paid and what would have come back.

Go straight to a quote

Skip the look back and have the group captive quote you.

If a button doesn't open your email, write to Brennan Ellis directly:

b.ellis@walkerhughes.com